Religion Information

The Stilling of the Storm


Matt. 8:23-27; Mark 4:35-41; Luke 8:22-25.

General Pericope Distinctions

In the gospel of Mark, the "stilling of the storm" and the whole sea sequence follow the day of parables. In Matthew, this story and the split sequence come in chapters eight and nine; the day of parables comes later in chapter 13. Luke agrees with Matthew in noting the presence of the disciples, Mark has an independent "they" throughout the passage and no mention is made of the disciples. Mark's command in 4:3 is omitted here by Matthew who uses it to introduce the preceding passage (8:18). In Luke and Mark, Jesus stills the storm first and then admonishes the disciples. In Matthews, the action is reversed; Jesus rebukes the disciples and then stills the storm. One of the oddest features in Matthew is that it begins the story with "the disciples" but ends with "the men."

Exegetical Interpretation

None of the synopsis' give specifics regarding the day and time when the stilling of the storm occurred. Mark and Luke simple indicate, "That day." Mark 4:35 shows that the crossing of the lake happened on the "evening" of the day when the discourse in parables had been pronounced. Luke suppressed the mention of the late hour of the day but his verse (22) can be easily harmonized if we view the first gospel as being topological rather than chronological.

When Jesus concluded His teaching, he commands the disciples to cross with Him to the other side of the Sea of Galilee. The reason for this decision is undisclosed and can therefore, only be conjectured. Seemingly, the prevailing view assumes that Jesus was enervated and desired rest from the pressuring crowd. Walter Bundy in his book "Jesus and the First Three Gospels," suggest the possibility that Jesus may have desired seeking a new sphere for his ministry which Mark 8:35-39 seem to support.

The disciples, obedient to the command of Jesus, board the boat with Him. In the Lukan form of the story, the phrase "and his disciples" would mean the twelve and the women of 8:1-3; cf. 8:9. This is in stark contrast to the vague Markan "they" and "them."

The "other side" was the district of Decapolis, east of the Sea of Galilee. This side was more rocky and barren and not as heavily populated with people as the western shore. Thus being, it became a natural refuge from the active life of the western coast.

The sudden "squall" as used by Mark and Luke was not extraordinary. The Sea of Galilee, which is said to be approximately 685 feet below sea level, was surrounded by mountains on almost all sides. Particularly at night ("as evening drew near") a storm could develop quickly.

The Greek word employed by Matthew, "tempest," properly translates "an earthquake," while "squall" as used by Mark and Luke signifies a "hurricane."

Mark add the graphic picture of the waves breaking into the ship and mentions the dangerousness of the predicament. In contrast to the raging sea and storm outside the ship, Jesus is sleeping serenely inside the ship. Luke depicts Jesus' falling asleep before he mentions the squall while Mark mentions it after he discusses the storm. Jesus' falling asleep suggests He was subject to human fatigue and required a human necessity - rest. There are theologians who propose Jesus wished to test the disciples' faith and others who add that Jesus' weariness may be considered voluntary because it was intended to assist the weakness of the disciples.

According to Mark, Jesus was "in the stern, sleeping on a cushion." Neither Matthew nor Luke mentions Jesus' location on board the boat. Luke omits the disciples' plaintive query about Jesus' nonchalance and apparent lack of concern about His and their welfare. The disciples awaken Jesus.

Most commentaries draw attention to the somewhat gentler versions of Matthews and Lukes' statements: "Lord, save us, we perish" (Mt. KJV), "Lord, save us, we're going to drown" (NIV), "Master, master, we're going to drown" (Lk., NIV), Master, master, we perish" (KJV). The most glaring feature is the boldness of Mark: "Do you not care if we perish" (RSV), "Master, carest thou not that we perish" (KJV), "Teacher, don't you care if we drown?" (NIV).

The cry expresses fear, panic and indignation and the disciples seem to hold Jesus responsible. The storm did not disturb Jesus but it obviously did the disciples. Death appears imminent to the "chosen ones" and they resent Jesus for having the temerity to sleep during the crisis. It is at that moment that the disciples' humanity prevailed over their faith and they were overtaken with fear.

Mark and Luke records Jesus' reproach of the disciples following the stilling of the storm. In Matthew, the opposite is true. Opinions seem divided as to the exact order. Paul Ryan in "Gospels of the Sundays" made this observation.

"St. John Chrysostom, preferring the order given by St. Matthew, speaks thus: 'Before Christ would still the tempest of waters, He, by this rebuke, first calmed the souls of His disciples. He did so that they might be in a better condition to witness the miraculous exercise of His divine power, and to learn the lesson which the miracle was intended to convey.'"

Jesus rebuked the wind and the waves and all became immediately quiet. It is Mark alone who gives the actual words Jesus spoke, "Peace, be still," which literally means "be muzzled." Barclay also notes that Jesus uses the exact same words here speaking to the wind as He had to the demon possessed man in Mark 1:28.

Jesus' reprimand to the disciples was sharp and may have been tinged with anger and disappointment. The disciples' faith was insufficient to enable them to believe that Jesus, though sleeping, was still watching over them by His divine power, and could save them.

Rev. Saundra L. Washington, D.D., is an ordained clergywoman, social worker, and Founder of AMEN Ministries. http://www.clergyservices4u.org. She is also the author of two coffee table books: Room Beneath the Snow: Poems that Preach and Negative Disturbances: Homilies that Teach. Her new book, Out of Deep Waters: My Grief Management Workbook, will be available soon.


MORE RESOURCES:

New York Times

Bishops Were Prepared for Battle Over Birth Control Coverage
New York Times
Seven months earlier, they had started laying the groundwork for a major new campaign to combat what they saw as the growing threat to religious liberty, including the legalization of same-sex marriage. But the birth control mandate, issued on Jan.
Biden says contraceptives fight can be worked outReuters
Catholic TV network sues US over birth control mandatemsnbc.com
Contraception rules must respect religion, healthSan Francisco Chronicle
U.S. News & World Report -Huffington Post (blog) -KSPR
all 3,847 news articles »


Medina Valley ISD settles prayer suit
Houston Chronicle
By Guillermo Contreras • School district personnel will not display crosses, Bibles or other Scripture, or religious images, quotations, icons or artifacts on school walls or hallways. • The district won't invite speakers, including government ...

and more »


Haley Barbour's Unintentional Lesson: Keep Religion and Governance Separate
Huffington Post
pre-determined who was eligible to be pardoned based upon their professing the adoption of his religion. Follow me on a not-so-hypothetical. Suppose that one felon claimed personal salvation, that he had found Jesus, while another made no such ...

and more »


Opposing Views

Evolution Weekend: Protecting Both Religion and Science
Huffington Post
This coming weekend hundreds of religious congregations from all corners of the globe will take steps to re-focus the political discussion about religion. Their goals are actually as simple as they are important. 1. To protect mainstream religion from ...
"Evolution Weekend" Merges Religion & ScienceOpposing Views
Responding to Darwinists Who Get Religion on Evolution Sunday: A Collection of ...Discovery Institute

all 10 news articles »


ABC News

'Why I Hate Religion, But Love Jesus' Creator Surprised by Critical Response ...
ABC News
"What if I told you Jesus came to abolish religion? … And just because you call some people blind doesn't automatically give you vision? … I mean if religion is so great, why has it started so many wars? Why does it build huge churches, ...
Jesus still a superstar as YouTube video spoofs conservative politicsHULIQ
Jesus versus the GOPSalon

all 7 news articles »


True Religion shares tumble on earnings, outlook
CBS News
True Religion Apparel Inc.'s shares tumbled almost 22 percent in after-hours trading Thursday after the clothing company posted fourth-quarter earnings that fell short of Wall Street expectations and gave a disappointing outlook for 2012.
True Religion 4Q Net Down 8.4%; Shares Slide On Weak ForecastWall Street Journal
True Religion Profit Down, Sees FY12 Below Street; Shares PlungeNASDAQ
True Religion Apparel Announces Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2011 Financial ...MarketWatch (press release)

all 21 news articles »


Mixing Art and Religion for a Loving Reunion
New York Times
Jane Shaw, who became the cathedral's dean last year, share a vision of bringing together art and religion, historically-linked pursuits that are sometimes at odds in modern America. While Grace Cathedral has been very involved with art and artists ...

and more »


Republicans Criticize Obama 'Attack' on Religion at Meeting
BusinessWeek
9 (Bloomberg) -- Republican leaders, seeking to rally conservatives at an annual gathering, accused President Barack Obama of assaulting religious liberty by requiring sectarian schools and hospitals to provide birth-control coverage to employees.

and more »


Actress Roma Downey on religion, faith (2:19)
Washington Post
"Touched by an Angel" star Roma Downey discusses her views on religion and faith with The Washington Post's Sally Quinn. (Feb. 9) (/The Washington Post) Correction: Clarification: SuperFan badge holders consistently post smart, timely comments about ...

and more »


Activision, Leapfrog, Lear, True Religion: US Equity Preview
BusinessWeek
True Religion Apparel Inc. (TRLG US): The seller of jeans' 2012 earnings and revenue forecasts missed the average estimate of analysts surveyed by Bloomberg. XL Group Plc (XL US): The insurer and reinsurer reported a fourth-quarter loss of 25 cents a ...
Activision, Leapfrog, Lear, LinkedIn, True Religion: U.S. Equity PreviewBloomberg

all 33 news articles »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006