Religion Information

Biblical Hermeneutics - Part 2


Should we be tempted to believe that our system of interpretation is the only system that has ever existed, Ramm makes it very clear in his discussion of the "historical schools" that this is not so. The "Battle for the Bible" may have, in fact, been born as the second century Christian exegetes, who were influenced by Jewish Biblical scholarship, espoused a literal reading of Scripture which assumed its historical accuracy and included a healthy respect for questions of context. Around the same time these interpreters (referred to by Ramm as the School of Antioch) were not exclusively concerned with the Bible's literal sense; they were equally concerned to interpret Scripture at a level that transcended its historical-literal dimension. This school of thought judged Scripture to be reliable and true on the basis of its conformity to orthodox Christian doctrine. In essence, Scripture judged the church, but it was the church who judged what was scriptural; and at this point the church was still involved in the process of assessing the value and authority of many Christian documents, only some of which made it into the canon.

Elsewhere, scholars trained as philosophers and rhetoricians, rejected as non-historical large portions of Scripture while simultaneously conferring total authority and reliability on all Scripture. The truth of Scripture, according to this school of thought, rested in its profound spiritual or symbolic significance. This allegorical method of exegesis is associated historically with those such as Origin, Augustine, Ambrose and Jerome.

Centuries later, the church was forced, more or less, to focus its attention of Scripture in a different way as the Reformers sought to alter its relationship to the church. Placing the church completely under the judgment of Scripture, they nevertheless developed their own system for evaluating the authority of Scripture in general and scriptures in particular. Martin Luther for example, considered those portions of Scripture which "preached Christ" superior to those that did not. In practice this meant that Luther granted more weight to Paul's words than to James'. It seems Calvin postulated a more objective authority for Scripture.

Even a diminutive exposure to the history of the church's involvement with Scripture gives us reason to pause and re-evaluate our too simple and long cherished assumptions about the nature of scriptural revelation. Before serious study, I was totally unaware of the extent to which disagreements about the nature of biblical inspiration and authority have permeated the church's history. The discovery, however, that some of the difficulties I encounter and must wrestle with are not unique and that some of the greatest minds the Church has ever known had similar problems to contend with is, at the very least, consoling and reassuring. An understanding of and appreciation for the presuppositions of other methods does, indeed, provide a more balanced perspective and a capacity for more meaningful dialogue with those who believe differently.

Although our goal is always to understand the meaning of biblical texts we make egregious mistakes if we fail to interpret a passage before gaining a clear and objective sense of what a given passage actually "says" and whether or not it actually "means" what it says. Because the Bible text may not mean what it seems to say due to the ambiguity of language, it is important that we resist the impulse to conjecture about the text's meaning until after careful study. The exegete must first discover the language conventions, syntactical meanings, and dennotative and connotative implications. This requires a study of word definitions and their relationship to one another which facilitates the possibility of accurately coming to the original meaning the author intended to convey.

And examination of the historical-cultural conditions is also important for it provides us with information about the text's authorship, dating, place of origin, occasion and purpose for writing, and the milieu in which the author wrote. Clearly, this type of information would greatly enhance our understanding and respect of the text's significance.

Any periscope chosen for study is also part of a larger collection of material, and the position it occupies in that collection provides us with a broader framework for comprehending what the passage may have meant originally both to its author and the community for which the writer wrote. Therefore, it is vital that we consider the relationship of the given text to the whole body of the writer's work in general and study the material that immediately precedes and follows the passage in particular. The literary context of a passage helps to focus the text for us and may provide us with significant clues for its interpretation.

I'm certain that the problems we encounter in Scripture are directly related to our lack of understanding of the words, ideas and concepts presented in it. Even when the words themselves are clear, the ideas they are attempting to express may seem remote or confusing.

Through access to standard reference tools we are supplied valuable information which first-century Christians would have considered common knowledge. Once we have possession of this information, the original meaning of words, statements, the text in general takes on a new significance and regains its power to excite and amaze us and to those to whose we preach or teach as they did the people to whom they were first addressed.

An abundance of resources are available to us which facilitates good exegesis. They include: the Bible in a variety of translations; lexicons, commentaries in a variety of languages, Bible dictionaries and encyclopedias, study manuals and concordances to name a few. Of course, these tools range from the highly critical variety - which often assumes a knowledge of Greek and Hebrew - to the purely devotional and over simplified.

(continued in Part 3)

Rev. Saundra L. Washington, D.D., is an ordained clergywoman, social worker, and Founder of AMEN Ministries. http://www.clergyservices4u.org. She is also the author of two coffee table books: Room Beneath the Snow: Poems that Preach and Negative Disturbances: Homilies that Teach. Her new book, Out of Deep Waters: My Grief Management Workbook, will be available soon.


MORE RESOURCES:

AFP

Boehner Calls HHS Contraception Mandate an 'Attack on Religious Freedom ...
ABC News (blog)
House Speaker John Boehner today called the Obama administration's move to compel nearly every employer to offer insurance that covers contraceptive services “an unambiguous attack on religious freedom in our country.” In an uncommon floor speech today ...
US Republicans: Obama attacking religionAFP
Obama's assault on religious freedomPolitico
Obama administration looking to resolve contraception controversyCNN (blog)
University of Wyoming News -CBS News -Washington Post (blog)
all 2,098 news articles »


Religion news in brief
San Jose Mercury News
One of the banners was signed by The Knights Templar, a violent, pseudo-religious cartel from the neighboring state of Michoacan. The cloth banners with hand-painted messages were found and quickly removed on Tuesday, a few weeks after the local Roman ...

and more »


Telegraph.co.uk

Proposition 8 and the new religious reality
Washington Post (blog)
In 2008, the “gays versus religion” frame was strongly entrenched in the mentality of the American public. Much of the driving force behind Prop 8, in terms of both organization and money, came from the leadership of the Roman Catholic and Mormon ...
Gay Marriage Ruling a Memo to Justice Kennedy: Noah FeldmanBloomberg
Prop 8: Why 18000 Is The Critical NumberABC News (blog)
Romney, Gingrich blast Prop 8 rulingCBS News
Yahoo! Contributors Network -Huffington Post -Big Government
all 3,198 news articles »


Lawsuit Filed Over Jesus Statue on Public Land
ABC News
The Freedom From Religion Foundation argued in their lawsuit that the Forest Service is unconstitutionally sanctioning the Catholic statue maintained by the Knights of Columbus. The religious nature of the statue has been made clear in special-use ...

and more »


California Catholic Daily

Religion: Contraceptives-coverage letter reopens chaplain debate
The Republic
In it, Archbishop Timothy Broglio joined with most of America's Catholic bishops in blasting new US Department of Health and Human Services rules that will require the vast majority of religious institutions to include free coverage of all Food and ...
Crossroads for freedom of religionNews & Observer
Obama Admin Silenced Catholic Army Chaplain on New MandateLifeNews.com
Archbishop to US Troops: Obamacare Reg 'Is a Blow to Freedom'Catholic Online
Human Events
all 36 news articles »


10 reasons religious conservatives love Rick Santorum
CNN (blog)
(CNN) - For all the attention paid to the clout of fiscally focused tea party conservatives and of the primacy of jobs in the 2012 election, Rick Santorum's trifecta victories Tuesday night are a good reminder of the powerful role religious ...

and more »


The Daily Star

Putin: Compulsory Religion Classes Must Engage Students
RIA Novosti
Prime Minister Vladimir Putin came out in favor of robust religion and secular ethics classes in Russian schools, saying they should be taught by theology specialists or priests. Banned during the Soviet era, religion classes returned to middle schools ...
Putin says specialists needed to teach fundamentals of religion at schoolsInterfax-Religion

all 291 news articles »


USA TODAY

Gay-marriage amendment would exclude religious-school chapels
The Seattle Times
Although the same-sex-marriage bill the House will vote on Wednesday is more accommodating to religion than the version introduced in the Senate, some worry it still doesn't go far enough. By Lornet Turnbull Is it too much to expect the truth on this?
GET UPDATES FROM Robert P. Jones, Ph.D.Huffington Post
Overheard on CNN.com: What is a 'marriage' anyway? Prop 8 commenters debateCNN (blog)
Growing Public Support for Same-Sex MarriagePew Research Center for the People and the Press

all 590 news articles »


Jornal.us News Agency

Church compelled to cover abortion services under new rule
Jornal.us News Agency
On January 20, the Department of Health and Human Services announced that it would not exempt health plans provided by non-profit religious employers from the requirement to provide “contraceptive services". This means that Catholics and other ...
Taking "religious freedom" too far?U.S. Catholic magazine (blog)
No One is Safe Under ObamaCareLubbockOnline.com (blog)
The Obama administration's abortion ruleBP News

all 45 news articles »


The Guardian

GOP Rivals Pounce on Romney's 'Assault on Religion' Line
ABC News (blog)
Mitt Romney's Republican rivals pounced today on his accusations that President Obama has an “assault on religion” by forcing Catholic institutions to provide contraceptives and abortion services, suggesting it was a hypocritical statement.
Santorum: Romney contraceptive decision 'trumped employees' religious consciences'Politico (blog)
Gingrich criticizes Romney, Obama, on religious freedomPekin Daily Times
Romney Attacks Obama for 'Assault on Religion'Wall Street Journal (blog)
Deseret News -CNN (blog) -CBS News
all 9,188 news articles »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006